I have often pondered about what we understand by the word "resource" within our experiences of learning. As students, we were situated in institutes, where libraries and teaching faculty became our resources of learning. But to what extent have we used these resources to their maximum potential? For instance, my mother used to set a vacation routine for me while I was in school, where I had to spend an hour every day reading from a ten-volume Britannica encyclopedia. I read the story-section again and again, day after day, year after year and ignored the sections on history, art, society, mythology, science and many others. I missed the opportunity to take all that the encyclopedia could have offered me.
India's art institutions have been taking the flak for failing to generate critical discourses and dialogue amongst the students, owing to the dearth of scholarly presence in the teaching faculty. While it is surely justified in pointing the finger towards the people responsible for imparting instruction, I would also ask what the students are doing with all the resources that are available to them at hand's reach? How much time or effort does it take to walk to the library, read the titles on the spines of books, pick one up and read the essays/ look at the visuals? Why doesn't curiosity drive one to the library to browse?
Even if we accept that today's world depends much more on the internet for information, why is it not being used to its potential? I would go even further to say to all the facebook junkies amongst the students that there too, they can find art resources as most Contemporary Art Galleries have facebook pages with frequent updates on all their events and exhibitions. Galleries and museums now host amazing websites that are interactive, informative and serve as superb resources. Art documentaries on television channels are also easily accessible.
Sudhir Patwardhan and Bhupen Khakhar are two examples of some of our finest artists and neither of them underwent academic art training. It is through the dialogue with their own peers, through their passion to seek information and through many hours of hard work in the studio that they created for themselves a niche in the history of contemporary Indian art. At a time when there was no internet and the world relied on 'snail mail' for communication, artists were compelled to make the best use of the limited resources and every opportunity that would enrich their art practice was treated with the utmost fervour of sincerity.
Over the past ten years, I have at different points of time searched on the internet for video art and the resources have consistently expanded and last year, I discovered http://www.vdb.org/
Is it because I have found myself in certain circumstances (like having to teach a class) to look for resources? May be. But most of the time, my own art practice has created circumstances for questioning, seeking and discovery.
I was recently introduced to www.theotherspaces.com. It is a wonderful intervention in the course of sharing art- history outside academic structures and I do believe that the some of the texts that are being archived on this website carry historical significance without which the comprehension of contemporary art today would be incomplete.
Theen Tamasha and friends created the following list of resources that may merely serve as a starting point to further one's information on art.
Malavika Rajnarayan
LIST OF CONTEMPORARY ART GALLERIES IN INDIA
Mumbai
Sakshi Gallery- www.sakshigallery.com
Gallery Chemould- www.gallerychemould.com
Pundole Art gallery- www.pundoleartgallery.in
Lakeeren gallery- www.lakeerengallery.com
Guild gallery- www.guildindia.com
Galerie Mirchandani+Steinruecke- www.galeriems.com
Gallery Maskara- www.gallerymaskara.com
Gallery BMB- www.gallerybmb.com
Delhi
Vadhera Art Gallery- www.vadheraart.com
Gallery Threshold- www.gallerythreshold.com
Nature Morte - www.naturemorte.com
Palette Art Gallery- www.paletteartgallery.com
Delhi Art Gallery- www.delhiartgallery.com
Gallery Espace - www.galleryespace.com
Khoj- www.khoj.in
Auction Houses
Saffron Art- www.saffronart.com
OSIAN’s- www.osians.com
Sotheby’s- www.sothebys.com
Christie’s- www.christies.com
Museum websites
National Gallery of Modern Art (NGMA), New Delhi, INDIA- www.ngmaindia.gov.in
National Museum, Delhi- www.nationalmuseumindia.gov.in/collection.html
Museum of Modern Art (MOMA), New York- www.moma.org
San Francisco Museum of Modern Art- www.sfmoma.org
Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York- www.metmuseum.org
Smithsonian museums, Washington D.C.- www.si.edu/museums
The National Gallery, London- www.nationalgallery.org.uk
TATE Modern, London- www.tate.org.uk/modern
The Victoria and Albert museum, London- www.vam.ac.uk
The British Museum- www.britishmuseum.org
The Louvre, Paris- France- www.louvre.fr
The Pompidou Centre- www.centrepompidou.fr
Museo Del Prado, Madrid- Spain- www.museodelprado.es
READING LIST
The following list is ONLY A SELECTION that is meant to lead one to more writings by the authors.
Geeta Kapur
Five Contemporary Indian Artists
When was Modernism
An Elegy for an Unclaimed Beloved: Nasreen Mohamedi (1937-1990)
The Evolution of Content in Amrita Shergil’s Paintings
K.G.Subramanyan (Monograph)
Quest for Identity (Vrischik Publication)
Gender Mobility: Through the lens of five women artists (Art and Visual Culture in India: 1987-2007 Marg Publication)
Inside Out: Women Artists of India
Partha Mitter
Indian Art
Triumph of Modernism- Indian Artists and the Avant Garde, 1922-1947
Indian artists in the colonial period: The case of Bombay (Art and Visual Culture in India: 1987-2007 Marg Publication)
K.G.Subramanyan
Moving Focus
Living Tradition
Creative Circuit
The Magic of Making- Essays on Art and Culture
R.Sivakumar
Benodebehari Mukherjee: Life, Context, Work
Culture specificity, Art language and Practice of Modernism: An Indian perspective (Contemporary Indian Art and Other Realities- Marg Publication)
Gulammohammed Sheikh
Ruminating on ‘Life of the Medieval Saints’ by Benodebehari Mukherjee
Ranjit Hoskote
The Enigma of Presence: Reflections on the Human Figure in Modern Indian Art (From ‘Celebration of the Human Image- The human figure in Indian contemporary painting)
The Complicit Observer (Sudhir Patwardhan’s monograph)
The Openness of Secrecy: Soliloquy and conversation in the art of Surendran Nair
Now that the trees have spoken- Catalogue essay of exhibition of Non-urban art at Pundole Art gallery
Chaitanya Sambrani
Edge of Desire- Recent Art in India
Shadows, Reflections and Nightmare: the Art of Nalini Malani
Navjot: Of response and responsibility (From Expressions and Evocations- Marg publication)
Rustom Bharucha
Another Asia: Rabindranath Tagore and Okakura Tenshin
Nilima Sheikh
Post-independence Initiative in Art
On Amrita Shergil: Claiming a radiant legacy (From the book Expressions and Evocations)
Nancy Adajania
Soloists in Shifting Ensembles: Bombay (text from (Chalo! India - A New Era of Indian Art)
New Media overtures before New Media practice in India(Art and Visual Culture in India: 1987-2007 Marg Publication)
India’s New Progressives- (from ART ASIA PACIFIC- 50TH ISSUE)
The Mutable Aesthetic of New Mediatic Realism- (From Art India Quarter IV- 2005)
Images of Conflict, Icons of Power (From Art India- Quarter 2, 2003)
Kamala Kapoor
Art of Vivan Sundaram
Nalini Malani: Memory Stress and Recall (From Expressions and Evocations- Marg publication)
All publications of SAHMAT- www.sahmat.org
www.theotherspaces.com has the following texts:
“Place for People”- Geeta Kapur
“Questions and Dialogue”- Anita Dube
“The Group 1890”- J. Swaminathan
“Cholamandal” - K.C.S. Panicker
“Progressive Artists Group”- F. N. Souza